Skip to content
4 min read Watchdog Wednesday watchdog-wednesday

Watchdog Wednesday: Heidi Overton’s Confirmation Hearing, By The Numbers

As usually happens at such events, Senators focused more – roughly 11 times as much – on hot button political issues than they spent on how drugs actually get approved.

Heidi Overton testifies at her Sept. 24 confirmation hearing.
"Senator, if confirmed, I'd be happy to." Source: Senate Broadcast

Watchdog has long thought that the most common statement at a confirmation hearing is a variant of the phrase “Senator, if confirmed, I look forward to working with you on that issue,” and Heidi Overton’s Sept. 24 confirmation hearing did not disappoint. Overton, currently deputy assistant to the president for domestic policy, seem on track to become the 28th commissioner of food and drugs after a strong performance that saw her face relatively hostile questioning from both sides of the aisle.

Overton used some version of “I’d be happy to work together on this” in nearly 10% of her spoken turns, and by wordcount, those phrases total about 3.3% of everything she said.

Of course, this does not mean that her time at FDA will be defined by collaborative activities with the Senate. Parsing what a commissioner might do based on their confirmation process is nearly impossible simply because unexpected events overtake any plans they might have. For example, Robert Califf got no questions about formula shortages, and Stephen Hahn received none about COVID.